Blu-ray Review: 3 Women — The Criterion Collection on Blogcritics.
One of Robert Altman’s best — and most atypical — films, 3 Women
is one of the best examples of a dreamlike aesthetic achieved on
celluloid. And like many dreams, this one elicits a wide panoply of
emotions, all at the same time. Like the bizarre half-human,
half-reptilian murals that Janice Rule’s character paints in the film, 3 Women
is unsettling but also mesmerizing. It’s a pleasantly hazy and
bewitching dream and a skin-crawlingly weird nightmare at the same time.
Altman regular Shelley Duvall stars as Millie Lammoreaux, an
attendant at a day spa for the elderly in the middle of the California
desert. Millie fancies herself a highly desirable modern woman, with the
fashion sense and recipe book to back it up. Too bad her perspective
isn’t shared by any of her coworkers or peers, who can barely muster the
disdain to make fun of her.
But there is one person absolutely enthralled with Millie — Pinky
Rose (Sissy Spacek), a wide-eyed girl just off the bus from Texas — who
loves Millie’s personality so much, she might just take it for her own.
She gets a job at Millie’s spa and soon becomes her new roommate. Millie
takes it upon herself to educate Pinky in the ways of the world and
introduces her to her social circle, including Willie and Edgar Hart
(Rule and Robert Fortier), a couple who own Millie’s apartment building
and a dilapidated amusement center named Dodge City.
The power hierarchy is clearly established initially, and one gets
the sense that Millie is grateful to finally have someone in her life
she’s socially superior to, but a dramatic mid-film decision by Pinky
starts to turn the world upside down. What seemed like plainly defined
relational roles are soon anything but, and it isn’t long before the
third woman of the title — Rule’s Willie — becomes part of the other
two’s lives in a horrifying way.
Many of Altman’s films have an affably shaggy sensibility, but 3 Women
is a much more controlled work with a carefully sustained aesthetic.
One never is quite at ease during the film, unsure of what Altman’s
trademark roving camera will spy next.
Both Duvall and Spacek are brilliant. In her sixth straight Altman
film, Duvall possesses an immense awareness of her character’s
personality (she crafted much of it on her own) while maintaining
Millie’s central obliviousness. She was one of Altman’s finest players,
and it’s a shame her career has essentially fizzled post-1980. Here,
Spacek is even creepier than she was in Carrie a year earlier, with a harmless-seeming veneer of naïveté that gives way to a seditious, seductive underbelly.
The ’70s were a great decade for Altman — he made masterpieces McCabe & Mrs. Miller, The Long Goodbye, Thieves Like Us and Nashville all within a five-year stretch — but even among that company and indeed, across his varied and fascinating career, 3 Women stands tall as a singular work.
The Blu-ray Disc
3 Women is presented in 1080p high definition with an aspect
ratio of 2.35:1. The film looks absolutely gorgeous, with the dusty
desert colors and the film’s symbols of ’70s kitsch showing
extraordinary color range and depth. Film grain is prominent but never
looks like noise, and lends to a pleasingly detailed transfer that looks
equally good in long shot and close-up. A few stray specks remain, but
damage has mostly been completely eradicated, and we’re left with a very
film-like, splendidly detailed picture.
Audio is presented in an uncompressed monaural soundtrack that shows
excellent range despite being limited to a mono mix. Dialogue is clean
and clear, with Gerald Busby’s atonal score exhibiting excellent
I wish we got more for the film, which is admittedly baffling in
spots, but Criterion simply ports over the small amount of extras from
its 2004 DVD release. Fortunately, the one big extra — an Altman
commentary track — is quite a good one. Altman recorded commentaries for
many of his films, and listening to the 3 Women track, it’s
clear why — he obviously enjoys it and excels at keeping things engaging
and lively. Here, he mixes production anecdotes with discussions of
theme and mood and filmmaking theory. He discusses the film’s
dream-initiated genesis, the relative ease with which he got financing
and the casting of Duvall and Spacek, who were both in the dream that
inspired the film. While he of course never gives anything so explicit
as an explanation, there are some good bits about identity and female
dominance that may help guide the utterly confused to some
Also on the disc is a large gallery of production photos and
publicity stills, which is well worth going through for the
behind-the-scenes looks, and a collection of trailers and TV spots. The
package also includes an insert with an essay by critic David Sterritt.
The Bottom Line
Top-tier Altman looking stunning on Blu-ray? This one’s easy to recommend.